www.globeandmail.com News Books Careers Mutual Funds Stocks ROB Magazine Technology
Home  |  Business  |  National  |  International  |  Sports  |  Features  |  Forums  |  Subscribe

The Globe and Mail
Saturday, Sep 18
leaf

Search

Tips & Other Options

Contents
bulletReport on Business
bulletNational
bulletInternational
bulletSports
bulletFeatures
bulletArts & Leisure
bulletCommentary
bulletFocus & Books
bulletAutomotive new
bulletClassifieds
bulletBirths & Deaths
bulletTravel
bulletHealth
bulletScience
bulletTechnology

Yellow.ca

News Index
bulletArts & Leisure
 Art
 Books
 Broadcast Week
 Fashion & Design
 Film
 Music
 Television
 Theatre
 TV Listings

bulletAutomotive new
bulletBirths & Deaths
bulletClassifieds
 Automotive
 Business Marketplace
 National personals
 Online personals
 Place an Ad
 Real estate rentals
 Real estate sales
 Services & Merchandise

bulletCommentary
 Editorials
 Editorial Cartoon
 Letters to the Editor
 Send letter to the Editor

bulletFeatures
 Amazing Facts
 Century of the Millennium
 Essay
 Fifth Column
 Life Story
 Lives Lived
 Millennium 100
 Social Studies
 Wax and Wane

bulletFocus & Books
 Book news
 Book reviews
 Focus Columns

bulletHealth
bulletInternational
 Columns
bulletNational
 Columns
 Issues Forum
 Report

bulletReport on Business
   - Staff Biographies
 Annual Reports
 Managing
 Money & Markets
 ROB Top 1000
 Small Business
 Smart Numbers
 Special Reports
 1999 Federal Budget

bulletScience
bulletSports
   - Staff Biographies
 Basketball
 Baseball
 Football
 Golf
 Hockey
 Other Sports

bulletTechnology
bulletTravel
Magazines
bulletROBmagazine.com
Special Interest
bulletCommunication Solutions new
bulletIT Management
bulletMillennium Series
 
Search Results

Migrants as money trees

SID TAFLER

Friday, September 17, 1999

IN BRITISH COLUMBIA -- It's an ugly scene: Chinese men and women locked up behind barbed wire on a naval base at the edge of a residential neighborhood near Victoria.

Uglier still when you realize that to those who sent them here, they are just a commodity designed to enrich an organized crime network based in the Far East and deeply embedded into the fabric of our own society.

This factor has stretched the bounds of our compassion for the 600 Chinese migrants that have appeared on our shores this summer. It's a terrible way to begin a new life, $40,000 in debt to a criminal gang that has no written contract but the power of extortion here and in China to enforce the indenture. Terrible for yourself and for your new adopted country.

Since the first migrants were swept up on the coast of British Columbia in July, the public has been engaged in an escalating war of words over their fate. Those who have written letters and carried pickets at the naval base welcoming the migrants claim a higher moral ground over those who would send them to China.

This is after all, British Columbia, part of a nation of immigrants and a land of great open spaces and opportunity. Along with that is its darker legacy of racial prejudice, often reflected in government policy designed to exclude, imprison or discriminated against immigrants and Canadians of Oriental descent.

Those who argue we can't accept the new migrants risk being associated with racists and alarmist headline writers who stoke the coals of anti-Chinese sentiment today. The other side of the debate says anyone who risked and suffered as much as these people have to make it to Canada deserves a chance. We may not like the way they got here, but the Fujianese farmers and factory workers smuggled in on rusty freighters had little practical hope of applying through officials channels at Canadian missions in China.

If there is a bottom line to this debate it's that millions of the dollars the migrants would earn in their first few years in Canada would go straight to the organized crime gangs that arranged for their passage.

That's about $40,000 each, with the payment period stretching over three to five years of low-paid work in Vancouver, Toronto or New York; higher pay for those who end up in the sex trade. That's $24-million before you calculate the interest rate of 15 per cent or more.

Surely our defective immigration policy warrants the scrutiny and debate that the wave of smuggled migrants has provoked. But few would disagree that our immigration standards and quotas must be determined by Canadians and their political leaders, not by criminal gang bosses.

When you catch a glimpse of the people behind the razor wire in their white jumpsuits, they seem fit, trim, young and eager. Eager to work at whatever job they're given, their lawyers tell us, even to spend 10 years in the Arctic to serve Canada.

It seems a failure of our own society that we can't protect these people from the snakeheads who send them here and control their lives when they arrive. But this may speak of another fault of our immigration system which allowed these organized crime operatives to gain entry to Canada.

We need no greater evidence of this gang control than the disappearance of some 40 migrants who were released from detention, likely bound for the sweatshops to begin repaying their debts.

The migrants tell their lawyers they fear for the safety of their families back in China if they try to escape the grasp of the criminal gangs.

Those fears were only increased by the appearance at the base detention centre last month of two lawyers from Vancouver. Evan Sahmet said he represented 17 of the migrants when he arrived in Victoria with his associate Kenneth Specht. Mr. Sahmet showed the identity card of one migrant and a letter supposedly written by the man's mother retaining him to represent the man.

But the migrant told Kevin Doyle, his assigned Victoria legal-aid lawyer, that the signature on the letter was not his mother's and that he didn't want Mr. Sahmet to represent him. A phone call back to the man's family in China revealed that someone had picked up his ID card at the family home after he left for Canada. The two lawyers failed to obtain any of the migrants as clients and returned to Vancouver. They refused to disclose how they obtained the ID card or the letter.

We may offer our sympathy to the migrants who risked everything to make it to our shores. Unfortunately, offering them what they most want, entry into Canada, would be a stunning victory for organized crime and another defeat for our faulty immigration system.

Sid Tafler is a writer and editor based in Victoria. E-mail: stafler@netbc.com

 
Noteworthy
Family Matters

Tracking the lives of Canadian families. September 11-18.


Student subscription
Get 50% off home delivery of The Globe and Mail.

Around our Globe contest
Congratulations to our final winners: Monique Wrubleski, Calgary, AB (weekend in Las Vegas) and Monti Fitzgerald, Burnaby, BC (flight for two to Florida). Thanks to all for participating!

Forums
East Timor
Diplomacy, sanctions, or UN military involvement. What would you recommend?

The Million Dollar Man
Too much money for child support? What do you think?

Books
Peter Watts, author of Starfish, hosts a discussion on science fiction as a genre at the end of the twentieth century. To join him click here.

Careers
"I believe that the IT skills shortage is being hyped by private and public training institutions who want to cash in on the demand for training." Do you agree?

Mutual Funds
What determinants do you use when selecting a particular mutual fund or fund company to invest in? Let us know in the globefund.com discussion forums.

Technology
"I don't think many people realize how insecure Web banking is. Would you use ATMs if all you had to do was put in a password and no card was required?" Big Bank Bust, in our forums.

Help & Contact Us
Back to the top of this page
Copyright © 1999 Globe Information Services