National Post Online - news
National Post
 News Financial Post Arts & Life Sports Commentary Diversions Forums


[Elections]

 Canada
 + News
 + Reporter
 + Politics
 + West to East

 World
 + News
 + Postcard
 + Observer


Careerclick

Special Features







Search Help
Sort by:
Date
Rank
 
Category


Thursday, September 16, 1999

U.S. heeded warning on illegal migrants; will Canada?


National Post

They have flooded British Columbia's prisons, diverted the attention of the RCMP from domestic issues, tied up the coast guard, taxed social services agencies and overwhelmed the Immigration Department.

And still the illegal Chinese immigrants, who have been arriving here in rusty freighters, keep washing ashore. Nearly 600 migrants have been intercepted on four ships so far this summer -- and there are warnings that more boats may be on the way.

Of course there are. China has a free-floating population of 150 million surplus workers, many of whom dream of finding jobs in the United States. And Canada's immigration policy has propped the back door wide open for them.

Experts say that stemming the tide of boat people will require a major law enforcement effort, coupled with significant changes in immigration policy. But so far, Ottawa has opted for a muted response.

"Canada is preparing for more ships and more refugees, but very little of the process has been changed," says Dr. Robert Bedeski, a political scientist and expert on northeast Asia security issues at the University of Victoria.

"This is playing a very dangerous game. The message is: come on over, you'll be received, fed, given clothing -- and set loose to continue to your destination."

Canada's non-response to the crisis contrasts sharply with what happened in the U.S. in 1993, after a single ship, carrying 300 illegal Chinese immigrants, tried to get ashore in New York City.

Shortly after 2 a.m. on June 7, a freighter ran aground on a sand bar just off Queens, N.Y., spilling a human cargo into the cold Atlantic. Ten drowned, 200 others, some dressed in business suits, some in their underwear, were pulled from the water, and 100 more were found huddled on the squalid ship, where they had lived under wretched conditions for three months. The Golden Venture -- a ship, incidentally, which had earlier visited Vancouver's harbour without attracting notice -- convinced the U.S. government that the human smuggling racket was both dangerous to the immigrants and a threat to the nation's stability. Within months of the Golden Venture incident, the Clinton Administration passed anti-alien-smuggling legislation, speeded up deportation hearings, stopped granting political asylum to those who said they were fleeing China because of its restrictive family planning laws, and had law enforcement agencies target organized crime associated with smuggling.

Within months, Kwok Ling-kay, the leader of Fuk Ching, one of New York's most powerful gangs, had been extradited from his base in China's Fujian province to face charges of organizing a human-smuggling ring. The crackdown curtailed smuggling directly to the U.S. -- but it also resulted in a shift to Canada and Mexico as the favoured points of entry. U.S. officials now say B.C. is the sole entry point for thousands of illegal Chinese entering their country from Canada every year.

Asked recently about the growing crisis on the West Coast, Jean Chretien, the Prime Minister, brushed it off as a minor problem. His comments indicated he has no understanding either of the magnitude of the situation, or its root causes.

Chinese officials said Canada should simply ship the migrants back to China, but Mr. Chretien responded by defending federal laws, which allow illegal aliens to claim refugee status, giving them two years to either make their case -- or sneak into the U.S.

"But it is the law we have had in Canada for a long time and I think we are not about to just return the people without hearing what they have to say," said Mr. Chretien, who apparently thinks the boat people intend to stay here.

"If you come by plane, you come by boat, you walk, you swim, when you are on the ground, you say 'I want to be a refugee,' and the law of Canada applies."

Mr. Chretien indicated he felt the illegal migrants were fleeing for good reason, because they "were not treated normally" at home.

In fact, researchers with the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, the U.S. National Science Foundation and the Center for the Study of Asian Enterprise Crime have all examined this issue in detail and concluded the same thing -- the immigrants are coming for economic reasons. They are coming to make money, not to flee oppression or to voice disfavour with the Communist regime.

"So, money is the major motive for them to come here to the United States, and a lot of people say, 'Well, U.S. dollars were the best thing on Earth. I often dream about having lots of U.S. dollars.' So, that's the number one reason," states Dr. Ko-Lin Chin, an associate professor at Rutgers University, School of Criminal Justice, based in New Jersey.

Mr. Chin interviewed 300 illegal immigrants working in New York City. They had been making an average wage of $50 a month in China. Doing menial jobs in New York's restaurant, construction and garment trades, they were earning $1,500 a month. Most could pay off their smuggling debts within three years. For them, the trip was an investment.

Paul George, an Asian expert, wrote a paper for CSIS in 1994 warning that an unbalanced economy on the Chinese mainland would lead to an exodus of young workers.

With farmers in China paid $173 (US) a year by the central government, and urban dwellers getting about $370, there was an economic disparity that would push people into the cities -- where there wasn't enough work. From there, they would look overseas.

"In a booming money culture, the peasants can no longer be kept on the farm by patriotic slogans and appeals to the state ideology," wrote Mr. George. "However, the peasants are caught in a poverty trap. Their incomes in the rural areas are in relative decline, yet the opportunities for finding rewarding work in the overcrowded coastal areas are also slim. Emigration is thus increasingly seen as a last chance to break the poverty cycle, and emigration 'services' have expanded to meet demand. Smuggling people for profit has become one more facet of the emerging market economy in China."

Mr. George's analysis for CSIS correctly predicted the U.S. crackdown on illegals would shift smuggling routes north.

"Canada should anticipate the arrival of large numbers of Chinese boat people off the Atlantic and Pacific coasts in the years to come," he stated. "A number of factors indicate that people-smuggling from China will become an increasingly serious problem ... the tide of illegal immigrants is expected to grow."

And he warned that the trend could threaten Canada's stability.

"Large population flows, regardless of whether they are legal or illegal, are potential(ly) destabilizing for the recipient countries ...

"Such concerns would include the political impact of the influx of massive numbers of people, especially in volumes that would swamp the capacity of the country's immigrant-processing facilities, challenge Canada's asylum policy, and cause domestic political problems."

Here on the West Coast, it is obvious the crisis point is approaching fast, but, as Bill Vander Zalm, the president of the Reform party in B.C., noted this week, it may take planeloads of illegal immigrants arriving in Ottawa to wake up the federal government.

In the meantime, expect the ships to keep coming.




RELATED SITES:

(Each link opens a new window)

  • Citizenship and Immigration Canada

    The brand-new white paper on immigration policy

  • Statistics Canada: Immigration and Citizenship

    Statistics from the 1996 national census that look at where Canadians came from.

  •  
     Home Site Map Feedback Info

    Copyright © Southam Inc. All rights reserved.
    Optimized for browser versions 3.0 and higher.