www.globeandmail.com News Books Careers Mutual Funds Stocks ROB Magazine Technology
Home  |  Business  |  National  |  International  |  Sports  |  Features  |  Forums  |  Subscribe

The Globe and Mail
Thursday, Sep 16
leaf

Search

Tips & Other Options

Contents
bulletReport on Business
bulletNational
bulletInternational
bulletSports
bulletFeatures
bulletArts & Leisure
bulletCommentary
bulletFocus & Books
bulletAutomotive new
bulletClassifieds
bulletBirths & Deaths
bulletTravel
bulletHealth
bulletScience
bulletTechnology

Yellow.ca

News Index
bulletArts & Leisure
 Art
 Books
 Broadcast Week
 Fashion & Design
 Film
 Music
 Television
 Theatre
 TV Listings

bulletAutomotive new
bulletBirths & Deaths
bulletClassifieds
 Automotive
 Business Marketplace
 National personals
 Online personals
 Place an Ad
 Real estate rentals
 Real estate sales
 Services & Merchandise

bulletCommentary
 Editorials
 Editorial Cartoon
 Letters to the Editor
 Send letter to the Editor

bulletFeatures
 Amazing Facts
 Century of the Millennium
 Essay
 Fifth Column
 Life Story
 Lives Lived
 Millennium 100
 Social Studies
 Wax and Wane

bulletFocus & Books
 Book news
 Book reviews
 Focus Columns

bulletHealth
bulletInternational
 Columns
bulletNational
 Columns
 Issues Forum
 Report

bulletReport on Business
   - Staff Biographies
 Annual Reports
 Managing
 Money & Markets
 ROB Top 1000
 Small Business
 Smart Numbers
 Special Reports
 1999 Federal Budget

bulletScience
bulletSports
   - Staff Biographies
 Basketball
 Baseball
 Football
 Golf
 Hockey
 Other Sports

bulletTechnology
bulletTravel
Magazines
bulletROBmagazine.com
Special Interest
bulletCommunication Solutions new
bulletIT Management
bulletMillennium Series
 
Search Results

Immigration fairness, not immigration folly
The government must turn illegal migrants
into lessons for their countrymen



Thursday, September 16, 1999

The spectre of the Komagata Maru is again haunting Canada. In 1914, that sad ship mostly full of potential Sikh immigrants was sent back to India after its passengers spent a hungry, uncomfortable two months unable to disembark in Vancouver.

The Sikhs weren't allowed to come here because the government of the day, not to mention many people of the day, didn't want Asians of any kind in their version of Canada. Subsequently, the Komagata Maru's fruitless voyage has come to symbolize the overtly racial prejudice of Canada's past immigration policy.

The image of the Komagata Maru is again before us as we watch ship after ship full of Chinese migrants steam across the Pacific, enter Canadian waters and then disgorge human cargo on our shores. However, this time our reaction is extraordinarily generous. The migrants are housed, fed Chinese food, given medical care, provided with legal counsel and allowed to plead their rights to stay here as refugees, even though both they and we know they are most likely economic migrants and not political refugees.

The irony is that today's boat people threaten to teach us a reverse Komagata Maru lesson. It seems our desire to be fair threatens to turn us into the world's patsies, or as Prime Minister Jean Chrétien has put it: "We have laws that induce some people to abuse the law."

With this as a background, it is vital that the migrants' cases be handled in a way that is not only fair to them, but fair to the spirit of our current high-minded immigration policy. Thus, we applaud Immigration Minister Elinor Caplan for deciding that the process of adjudicating the Chinese migrants' claims be speeded up. If, in three years, most of them are still here in some sort of refugee appeal limbo, we will have sent exactly the wrong message to their countrymen.

We also applaud holding the migrants in detention until their cases can be decided. Releasing the first group of them has been disastrous from a public-relations perspective. More than half of the boat people have gone missing and are presumed to be underground either here or in the United States.

In a larger sense, one also counsels the immigration lawyers who are advising the Chinese to think of the good of the whole. If lawyers cynically suggest that migrants apply for refugee status when those same lawyers know perfectly well the Chinese are not true refugees, it threatens to damage our communal sense of fairness -- not to mention breaking general rules of professional conduct espoused by law societies.

If legal deviousness prevents a scrupulously fair refugee adjudication system from working, Canadians will demand it be replaced with an unfair system that does work.

Finally, we must break the illegal boat migration cycle. If, as seems likely, most migrants are not true refugees, we should deport them back to their villages in China to spread a cautionary message.

They will tell others, look, an illegal boat trip doesn't carry you to a Golden Mountain but to a Canadian prison. The mountain you find is a debt mountain built from the money you still owe to people smugglers. Better to improve the Chinese economy than to try to sneak away to Canada.

In order to ensure this lesson is driven home, the Chinese government must be true to its most recent statement that "repatriation . . . is the best way to shatter [the migrants'] . . . expectations." The Chinese must make it easy for illegals -- even if they have destroyed their identification papers -- to be deported back to their homes in Fujian province. While officials are saying the right things now, it is also true that in the past the Chinese have not always expedited repatriation of Fujian migrants.

All this must occur so that we don't abandon our noblest instincts. If the present system does not expeditiously separate a true refugee from an economic migrant, it will be hard to stifle a return to a Komagata Maru-type response. You hear it already in those angry voices calling for future Chinese migrant ships to be turned back on the high sea -- no matter what the danger is to their passengers.

The government must continue along the course it has struck and demonstrate both to Canadians and to the world that immigration fairness does not inevitably lead to immigration folly.

 
Noteworthy
Family Matters

Tracking the lives of Canadian families. September 11-18.


Special Coverage: Connecting with Canadian E-Shoppers

Special coverage: Connecting with Canadian E-Shoppers.

Forums
East Timor
Diplomacy, sanctions, or UN military involvement. What would you recommend?

A New Governor-General
A new governor-general has been appointed. What do you think?

Books
Peter Watts, author of Starfish, hosts a discussion on science fiction as a genre at the end of the twentieth century. To join him click here.

Careers
"I believe that the IT skills shortage is being hyped by private and public training institutions who want to cash in on the demand for training." Do you agree?

Mutual Funds
What determinants do you use when selecting a particular mutual fund or fund company to invest in? Let us know in the globefund.com discussion forums.

Technology
"I don't think many people realize how insecure Web banking is. Would you use ATMs if all you had to do was put in a password and no card was required?" Big Bank Bust, in our forums.

Help & Contact Us
Back to the top of this page
Copyright © 1999 Globe Information Services