www.globeandmail.com News Books Careers Mutual Funds Stocks ROB Mag ROBTv Tech Wheels
Home  |  Business  |  National  |  International  |  Sports  |  Features  |  Arts  |  Forums  |  Subscribe

The Globe and Mail
Wednesday, May 24
leaf

7-Day Search
space

Tips | What Can I Search?
onvia.com

Contents
bulletFull Site Index
Click for a detailed list of everything on the site.


Main Sections
bulletReport on Business
bulletNational
bulletInternational
bulletSports
bulletGlobe Review
bulletFeatures
bulletComment
bulletFocus
bulletBooks
bulletClassifieds
space
Other Sections
bulletTravel
bulletReal Estate
bulletHealth
bulletScience
bulletTechnology
bulletEnvironment
bulletEducation
bulletObituaries
bulletBirths & Deaths
bulletToronto News
space
Specials & Series
bulletBudget 2000
bulletFamily Matters
bulletHomelessness
space
Entertainment
bulletCartoon
bulletCrosswords
bulletHoroscopes
bulletTV Listings
space
bulletFood & Dining
space
NorstarMall.ca

Chapters.ca
Current Markets
Enter Canadian or U.S. stock symbol(s) or market index:
 
Stock symbol lookup

Sponsored by:
HSBC InvestDirect


TSE 300 +1.70 8988.30
DJIA +55.85 10478.12
S&P500 +11.81 1385.67
Nasdaq -11.1 3153.4
CDNX -53.00 3262.3
FTSE100 +20 6107
Nikkei -274.3 16044.4
HSeng -323 13934
DJ Net -4.91 222.64
Delayed 20 minutes. Help.
Services
bulletFull Services Index
Click for a detailed list of everything on the site.


bulletAdvertise: Newspaper
bulletAdvertise: Web Sites
bulletCustomer Service
bulletCorrections
bulletFree Headlines
bulletHelp & Contact Us
bulletMake Us Home
bulletPrivacy Policy
bulletReprints
bulletSubscriptions
bulletWhat's New

Globe Web Centre
bulletNews: globeandmail.com
bulletBooks: chaptersglobe.com
bulletCareers: globecareers.com
bulletMutual Funds: globefund.com
bulletStocks: globeinvestor.com
bulletROB Magazine: robmagazine.com
bulletROBTv:       robtv.com
bulletTechnology: globetechnology
bulletWheels: globemegawheels
 
Search Results

Canadians quiet on Chinese human rights record

Madelaine Drohan

Wednesday, May 24, 2000

Ottawa -- It is puzzling that Canada's trade negotiations with China last year raised barely a murmur of dissent in the national media, whereas a similar set of talks between China and the United States have raised a storm of protest south of the border.

For weeks now, U.S. newspapers and television have featured blow-by-blow accounts of the fight between supporters and opponents of a bill before Congress to normalize trade relations with China. Congress votes today on whether to give up its annual review of trade with China. It must do so if China is to gain entry into the World Trade Organization.

Human rights groups and environmental activists in the United States are aghast. Without a yearly reckoning, they say, the Chinese authorities could become more abusive. How could Congress be so short-sighted?

The question being raised in this column is not whether the U.S. Congress should give up this review. Rather, it is why the hue and cry raised by U.S. opponents to normalizing trade with China is so extraordinarily loud and energetic compared with the almost non-existent protest in Canada.

Do Canadians not care as much about human rights and democracy? Probably. But we are missing a few of the key ingredients that have made trade with China such a volatile issue in the United States.

The first is so obvious it risks being overlooked. We are not a superpower and thus do not worry constantly about emerging rivals. Nor do we have all the attendant pressure groups that superpower status attracts. Our relations with China generally take place against a more placid backdrop. They've been buying our wheat for 40 years and we've been eager to sell it.

This is not to say that political questions do not figure in our relationship. But the Canadian government has taken the view that the current regime is benign. Otherwise, why would Ottawa have deported back to China last month 90 of the 590 boat people who washed up on the West Coast last summer in search of a better life?

Second, the prime minister does not see ushering China into the league of trading nations as a legacy issue in quite the same way as U.S. President Bill Clinton. The U.S. Administration has pulled out all the stops trying to get the China bill through Congress. This has provoked opponents to louder protests against the bill.

Third, this is an election year in the United States. Matters that might be ignored or quietly dealt with in other years become major issues when votes hang in the balance. Groups with money have extraordinary clout with candidates hungry for funds to feed their campaign machines.

Organized labour and big business have taken opposite sides on the China trade question and are vying with each other to secure support in Congress. Their attempts to publicize their positions in television and newspaper ads have raised public awareness.

The unions fear increased trade with China will mean lost jobs for their members. They have been courting candidates up for re-election with promises of campaign support. Bilateral trade between the United States and China is currently one-tenth of U.S. bilateral trade with Canada and one-third of bilateral trade with Mexico, but it will grow with more normal trade relations.

Business groups have been pushing hard in the other direction. They have their eye on the Chinese market of 1.2 billion people, some of whom have become increasingly sophisticated consumers as China has begun opening its economy to the world.

Business, too, is using its money to buy Congressional votes. And, in a break from the past, business groups are not fighting a proposed side agreement to the China bill on human rights. If that is what it takes to get the bill through Congress, they are willing to go along.

It's not as if we don't have unions and big business in Canada with roughly the same views. But we don't have an election forcing them to take out their wallets or start promoting their views. And even if we did, they don't have the same clout with candidates here as they would in the United States because of our campaign finance laws.

There is one last point. Canadians can get pretty worked up on the bilateral relationship with the United States because it accounts for more than 80 per cent of our merchandise trade. Trade with China is miniscule by comparison. This helps explain why we are content to let others fight loudly about whether China should be brought back into the trade fold. We might care, but not enough to do anything about it.
Madelaine Drohan's e-mail address is mdrohan@globeandmail.ca

 
Noteworthy
The Globe wins four top prizes
Stackhouse honoured twice, for international reporting and for series on the homeless.
Family Matters
Story & discussion: What makes a happy family?
Discussion Forums
bullet Nurturing Nature
Why are Canada's national parks dying and what can be done to save them?
Rick Searle, author of Phantom Parks, joins the discussion.

[ Join In ]
globeandmail.com

bullet Sierra Meltdown
Should Canada commit troops to Sierra Leone?

[ Join In ]
globeandmail.com

bullet Sex, Work and Stress
Do you agree with the survey results? How stressed out are you?

[ Join In ]
globeandmail.com

bullet Losing Local News
What do you think of the new proposed cutbacks at the CBC? Is the CBC your only source for local news?

[ Join In ]
globeandmail.com

bullet Bill 11
Alberta's private health-care bill. Should private clinics to be paid public funds to perform some medical procedures?

[ Join In ]
globeandmail.com


bullet E-trepreneurs
If you are an Internet entrepreneur, this is the place for networking. Ask and answer questions, post suggestions, or just read the comments of others.

[ Join In ]
globetechnology.com

bullet The state of the environment in Canada
Are ideological abstractions making us counterproductive?

[ Join In ]
chaptersglobe.com

bullet Battle of the Sexes
Are gender relations strained at work?

[ Join In ]
workopolis.com

bullet Volatility
Has the excessive volatility in the markets prevented you from being more speculative or encouraged you to trade more?

[ Join In ]
globefund.com

Weather
Calgary 18 Partly Cldy
Charlottetown 15 Cloudy
Edmonton 17 Partly Cldy
Fredericton 14 Rain
Halifax 15 Cloudy
Iqaluit 2 Icy Rain
London 21 Partly Cldy
Montreal 21 Rain
Ottawa 19 Showers
Prince George 15 Showers
Quebec 15 Rain
Regina 20 Partly Cldy
Saint John 12 Rain
St. John's 9 Rain
Saskatoon 20 Partly Cldy
Sault Ste Marie 16 Rain
Thunder Bay 18 Showers
Toronto 21 Showers
Vancouver 17 Sunny
Victoria 18 Sunny
Whitehorse 11 Showers
Windsor 24 Partly Cldy
Winnipeg 18 Partly Cldy
Yellowknife 15 Cloudy

Morning Smile
A fish singing the blues: I'm so lonely I could fry.
- Michael Dufresne and Katherine Lagrandeur, Kingston, Ont.

Help & Contact Us | Copyright © 2000 Globe Interactive | Back to the top of this page

Home  |  Business  |  National  |  International  |  Sports  |  Features  |  Review  |  Forums  |  Subscribe