www.globeandmail.com News Books Careers Mutual Funds Stocks ROB Magazine Technology
Home  |  Business  |  National  |  International  |  Sports  |  Features  |  Forums  |  Subscribe

The Globe and Mail
Saturday, July 31
leaf

Contents
bulletReport on Business
bulletNational
bulletInternational
bulletSports
bulletFeatures
bulletArts & Leisure
bulletCommentary
bulletFocus & Books
bulletClassifieds
bulletBirths & Deaths
bulletTravel
bulletHealth
bulletScience
bulletTechnology

Search

Tips & Other Options

Yellow.ca

News Index
bulletArts & Leisure
 Art
 Books
 Broadcast Week
 Fashion & Design
 Film
 Music
 Television
 Theatre
 TV Listings

bulletBirths & Deaths
bulletClassifieds
 Automotive
 Business Marketplace
 National personals
 Online personals
 Place an Ad
 Real estate rentals
 Real estate sales
 Services & Merchandise

bulletCommentary
 Columns
 Editorials
 Editorial Cartoon
 Letters to the Editor
 Send a letter to the Editor

bulletFeatures
 Amazing Facts
 Century of the Millennium
 Essay
 Fifth Column
 Life Story
 Lives Lived
 Millennium 100
 Social Studies
 Wax and Wane

bulletFocus & Books
 Book news
 Book reviews

bulletHealth
bulletInternational
 Columns
 The Globe Abroad

bulletNational
 Columns
 Issues Forum
 Report

bulletReport on Business
   - Staff Biographies
 Annual Reports
 Enterprise
 Managing
 Money & Markets
 ROB Top 1000
 Smart Numbers
 Special Reports
 1999 Federal Budget

bulletScience
bulletSports
   - Staff Biographies
 Basketball
 Baseball
 Football
 Golf
 Hockey
 Other Sports

bulletTechnology
bulletTravel
Magazines
ROBmagazine.com
Special Interest
Millennium Series
IT Management
 
Search Results

Chinese illegals? Remember the Komagata Maru

PAUL SULLIVAN

Saturday, July 31, 1999

IN VANCOUVER -- The 123 bedraggled, handcuffed illegal Chinese immigrants enjoying the accommodations at CFB Esquimalt while officials decide what to do with them have already made one major contribution to Canada. They've rescued British Columbia from its annual preoccupation with salmon, a story that's about as interesting as the codfish story on that other coast.

As usual, Alaskans and Indians are catching salmon while everyone else sits on the shore and stews. But this summer, the ocean has yielded a peculiar bounty in uninvited guests, and everyone wants to know just what they think they're doing.

Why would anyone travel 38 days locked in the cargo hold of a filthy, leaky, rusted old freighter just to be arrested and sent back to an uncertain fate in Fujian province, Peoples' Republic of China -- unless they knew all along that would never happen?

No, instead of putting them on the next plane to Hong Kong or someplace, good old Canada has taken them ashore, provided them with a gaggle (a pride? a billable brace?) of lawyers and sent out for Chinese food from Ming's, all at public expense, as their refugee claims are processed. They're not even grateful, staging a brief hunger strike apparently in protest against the quality of Ming's noodles.

If it goes the way these things normally go, their desperate gamble will pay off. Most will be found eligible for a refugee hearing and released. Then if they're anything like 70.8 per cent of illegal Chinese immigrants, they will fail to show up at their hearing. But from there, it's not exactly the Joy Luck Club. They have no choice but to go underground and become virtual slaves to work off the price of their ticket to the Free World -- as high as $50,000.

As you might expect, the boat people are just as big or bigger in the local and national Chinese media as they are in the Vancouver Province. The Province set the tone for this sort of thing back in 1914, when 374 Indians, most of them Sikhs, set sail from Hong Kong on the Komagata Maru. "Boat Loads of Hindus on Way to Vancouver," read the headline.

The story of the current band of illegals was still dominating the front page of the western edition of Ming Pao Daily on Wednesday. It warranted seven stories and two full colour photos a full week and a day after the boat people threw themselves on the mercy of the Coast Guard.

On a popular daily talk show on Fairchild Radio, calls have been running firmly in favour of "repatriating" them with dispatch. Apparently blatant queue-jumping seems just as unfair to recent Chinese immigrants as it does to most other Canadians. But the callers are also worried that if we let the boat folks stay in the World's Best Country (third year running -- The UN) it will only encourage more illegal-people smuggling.

And here's one even the right-wing press won't dare to run up the flagpole: Many callers argue that the refugee process is overly humanitarian and the government is wasting too much money on illegal immigrants.

Hold on there, argues high-profile Ming Pao columnist Aaron Chu, who is appalled by this widespread hard-heartedness, or at least hard-headedness. He wonders if these callers really understand the essence of what it is to be Canadian. A real Canadian, he argues, takes a rather humanitarian approach to people of different ethnic origins.

Oh. More than a few real Canadians can't wait to summarily convict the Esquimalt 123.

However, T.N. Foo of S.U.C.C.E.S.S., the Vancouver Chinese immigrant agency, points out that there are genuine refugees in China who, for political reasons, aren't able to make it to a Canadian embassy. Their only recourse is to risk their lives, their fortunes and their freedom to escape. Still, he emphasizes in his best Canadian way, all illegal refugees should be treated equally and rationally and lawfully.

Of course, nobody likes a sneak, regardless of race, colour or creed. There are thousands of legitimate refugees living in execrable conditions around the world who have applied to enter Canada and don't have a prayer. Part of the blame must go to illegitimate refugees who take their places, clog up the system and harden the hearts of Real Canadians to the plight of those, who by choice or by circumstance, are called refugees.

Still, it might do to remember the Komagata Maru. After it was turned back, it was forced to land in Calcutta, a skirmish broke out and 20 passengers were shot dead by British police. By illegally exiting China, the Esquimalt 123 have become people without a country, their only state a state of peril. Sending them back is not a Real Canadian thing to do, whether we like it or not.

Paul Sullivan is a Vancouver writer and consultant.

 
Noteworthy
· Editorial Cartoon
· Series archive
· What's new

Forums
The hidden danger of peacekeeping
The Canadian army has been accused of tampering with the medical files of soldiers in Croatia who came back to Canada with severe health problems. Is the military covering up its wrongful actions?

Books
Book clubs: Are they enlightening or frightening? Share your book club stories here.

Poetry: Share your poetry.

Careers
"I believe that the IT skills shortage is being hyped by private and public training instituitions who want to cash in on the demand for training." Do you agree?.

Mutual Funds
Aside from past performance, what's the most important criterion you examine when choosing a particular fund for your portfolio? Let us know on globefund.com.

Technology
Compaq has a new CEO, but anaylsts are skeptical he can do the job. What do you think? The new face of Compaq.

Help & Contact Us
Back to the top of this page
Copyright © 1999 The Globe and Mail