Invasion by poor a myth
www.globeandmail.com News Books Careers Mutual Funds Stocks ROB Magazine Technology
Home  |  Business  |  National  |  International  |  Sports  |  Features  |  Arts  |  Forums  |  Subscribe

The Globe and Mail
Monday, August 23
leaf stats

Search

Tips & Other Options
Contents
bulletReport on Business
bulletNational
bulletInternational
bulletSports
bulletFeatures
bulletArts & Leisure
bulletCommentary
bulletFocus & Books
bulletClassifieds
bulletBirths & Deaths
bulletTravel
bulletHealth
bulletScience
bulletTechnology

NorstarMall.ca

Yellow.ca

News Index
bulletArts & Leisure
 Art
 Books
 Broadcast Week
 Fashion & Design
 Film
 Music
 Television
 Theatre
 TV Listings

bulletBirths & Deaths
bulletClassifieds
 Automotive
 Business Marketplace
 National personals
 Online personals
 Place an Ad
 Real estate rentals
 Real estate sales
 Services & Merchandise

bulletCommentary
 Columns
 Editorials
 Editorial Cartoon
 Letters to the Editor
 Send a letter to the Editor

bulletFeatures
 Amazing Facts
 Century of the Millennium
 Essay
 Fifth Column
 Life Story
 Lives Lived
 Millennium 100
 Social Studies
 Wax and Wane

bulletFocus & Books
 Book news
 Book reviews

bulletHealth
bulletInternational
 Columns
 The Globe Abroad

bulletNational
 Columns
 Issues Forum
 Report

bulletReport on Business
   - Staff Biographies
 Annual Reports
 Enterprise
 Managing
 Money & Markets
 ROB Top 1000
 Smart Numbers
 Special Reports
 1999 Federal Budget

bulletScience
bulletSports
   - Staff Biographies
 Basketball
 Baseball
 Football
 Golf
 Hockey
 Other Sports

bulletTechnology
bulletTravel
Magazines
ROBmagazine.com
Special Interest
Millennium Series
IT Management

Services Index
bulletA Globe History
bulletAbout globeandmail.com
bulletAdvertise
 Newspaper
 Web sites

bulletCustomer Service
 Change of Address
 General Inquiry
 Office information
 Subscribe to the paper
 Subscribe: International
 Subscribe: Gift
 Subscribe: Renewal
 Vacation Suspension

bulletHelp & Contact Us
bulletLink To Us
bulletMake Us Home
bulletNewspaper Assoc.
bulletPrivacy Policy
bulletReprints
 Information
 Order form

bulletStory Search
bulletWeekday Lineup
bulletWhat's New
 
Invasion by poor a myth
Statistics show the number of impoverished
refugees making claims is dropping

MARCUS GEE
The Globe and Mail
Monday, August 23, 1999

It was a Frenchman, Jean Raspail, who best captured the anxiety of the rich world about an invasion of the poor.

In his apocalyptic 1973 novel The Camp of the Saints, he portrays a future in which Europe is besieged by more than a million hungry migrants from India, who arrive on the Mediterranean coast of France in an armada of small boats.

"The nations are rising from the four corners of the earth," says one of Mr. Raspail's characters, "and their number is like the sand of the sea."

Mr. Raspail's nightmare haunts us all. Rich countries have worried for decades about being overwhelmed by desperate migrants from the Third World.

For a while this summer, that fear seemed justified. When two boatloads of undocumented Chinese arrived on the West Coast, many Canadians worried that admitting them would open the floodgates to a tide of economic migrants posing as refugees.
The Germans, British, Americans and French fear the same thing.

So far, it has not happened. Despite the widening gap between the world's rich North and poor South, the vast majority of the world's poor stay put unless forced to move by war or some other catastrophe. And the majority of those who do leave go to other poor countries, not rich ones.

The fear of uncontrolled immigration is a bit like the fear of crime. The anxiety keeps rising, but the numbers (like the crime rate) are falling.

The number of people who arrived in rich countries to claim refugee status has dropped steadily in the past few years, from 891,000 in 1992 to 489,400 in 1997. Canada recorded about 24,000 refugee claims last year, about two-thirds the level in the early 1990s. The entire group would only half fill the Toronto SkyDome, and only half of those have been officially accepted as refugees.

"All developed countries have leaks in their immigration systems, and they are thrusting their fingers into the cracks," said Demetrios Papademetriou, an expert at Washington's Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. "But the dam is not breaking under any circumstances."

Mr. Papademetriou is careful not to dismiss the concerns of Canadians about uncontrolled immigration. But he does ask them to consider the following facts:

About 100 million to 120 million people live outside their countries of origin, a mere 2 per cent of the world's population. The vast majority of these live in poor countries and never attempt to migrate to the North.

Most of the world's roughly 12 million refugees also stay in the poor world, usually moving to countries next to their own.

Seven of eight immigrants who have moved to rich countries have done so by legal, regulated channels.

That is not to say that illegal immigration isn't a problem. Most rich countries have struggled with one kind or another of unwelcome arrival. More than 200,000 illegals cross into the United States from Mexico every year. Thousands of Albanians are smuggled by speedboat to Italy.

British authorities estimate that organized gangs are smuggling more than 2,000 illegal migrants and would-be refugee claimants into the country every month. Tension over the issue has reached such heights that violence broke out last week in the quiet English coastal port of Dover, with residents battling refugee claimants in the streets.

Even insular Australia has its troubles. Last Thursday, Australia returned a group of 101 boat people to China after apprehending them off the country's far north. Like the boat people who arrived off the coast of British Columbia, the Chinese had paid tens of thousands of dollars for a chance at a better life in a developed country.

But, hard as some migrants try, it's getting tougher and tougher to enter the rich world by the back door. The United States has doubled the number of guards along the Mexican border and built kilometres of new fences. Spain is spending more than $200-million on radar and night-vision equipment to stop Africans from sneaking across the Strait of Gibraltar.

Meanwhile, almost every rich country has tightened its entry rules for migrants. Germany cut off welfare benefits to refugee claimants and started turning back those who passed through safe third countries such as Poland. Britain fingerprints all refugee claimants and undocumented visitors. Australia is introducing 20-year prison sentences for people smugglers.

Canada's rules are softer than most, but even Ottawa now requires anyone coming from a refugee-producing country to have a visa. It also penalizes airlines that let travellers come on board without proper documents.

"It's actually very hard to get to Canada," said David Matas, a Winnipeg lawyer and refugee advocate.

Unless they come by plane, which is now much harder without documents, unauthorized migrants must either sneak in through the United States or make a costly, dangerous voyage across the ocean by boat.

Mr. Matas noted that the two boatloads of Chinese are the first such arrivals since a freighter carrying 174 Sikhs from India arrived in Nova Scotia in 1987. Though such incidents seize media attention, the numbers of migrants are a drop in the bucket and the public reaction is "wildly irrational," he said.

Legal immigration is down throughout the rich world. Canada had expected to take between 200,000 and 220,000 immigrants this year, but lowered its estimates by 20,000 because it got fewer applications than expected.

"There is a lot of fearful anticipation about immigration, but it just isn't borne out," said Kathleen Newland, a Washington-based immigration expert.

That fact looks even more amazing in light of how fast the population is growing in poor countries and how far they have fallen behind the rich. The share of the world's population that lives in poor countries has grown by 250 per cent in the past 50 years.

Given all that, what's really remarkable is not how many poor migrants wash up on Canada's shores, but how few.



More International News
Quake reveals best and worst of Turkey
Volunteers driving supplies to demolished cities while others are robbing corpses of jewellery
by Geoffrey York - Monday, August 23, 1999

Hundreds of thousands flee inland as hurricane slams into Texas coast
- Monday, August 23, 1999

Invasion by poor a myth
Statistics show the number of impoverished refugees making claims is dropping
by Marcus Gee - Monday, August 23, 1999

Plane crashes and flips at Hong Kong airport
Two killed during landing in tropical storm; five Canadians reported among survivors
- Monday, August 23, 1999


Search
Search up to one week back for the selected parts of The Globe and Mail that we have online. See tips & other options for help.


 
Noteworthy
Click here for the Editorial Cartoon

Special Series Archive
Archived features from The Globe and Mail.

What's New
The latest additions to globeandmail.com.

Writers
Cook

Peter Cook
· Articles


Knox

Paul Knox
· Articles



Bureaus
USWashington

USNew York

ChinaChina

EuropeEurope

MoscowMoscow

ChaptersGLOBE.com
Related Books
· Current Events
· History
· Politics & Government
· Reference & Language
· Travel

Help & Contact Us
Back to the top of this page
Copyright © 1999 Globe Information Services